Home > News > National/Global > Study claims homosexuality can be treated through faith
Banner
Study claims homosexuality can be treated through faith PDF Print
Written by Douglas Bridges-O’Connor, Daily Vidette Senior Staff   
Tuesday, 25 October 2011 16:06

A study conducted by two professors from religiously affiliated universities claims that gay individuals can change their sexual orientation through participation in a ministry program.

“Mark Yarhouse and I found, in terms of the average changes on the measures we used of sexual orientation, that on average going through the Exodus Ministries process produced statistically significant change away from homosexual orientation and towards heterosexual orientation,” Stanton Jones, psychology professor at Wheaton College, said.

Jones and co-author Mark Yarhouse, mental health professor at Regent University, published their findings in The Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy on Sept. 26.

According to the study, 98 individuals originally agreed to take part in the study. However, 37 eventually dropped out of Exodus Ministries, a Christian affiliated program for individuals struggling to rectify the conflict between their sexual orientation and religious beliefs.

According to the study, another 43 percent either did not respond to the ministry’s treatment or embraced their homosexual orientation. The remaining four percent reported feelings of confusion in regard to their sexual orientation 

Of the remaining 61 participants, consisting of both men and women, “53 [percent] were categorized as successful outcomes by the standards of Exodus Ministries. Specifically, 23 [percent] of the subjects reported success in the form of successful ‘conversion’ to heterosexual orientation and functioning, while an additional 30 [percent] reported stable behavioral chastity with substantive dis-identification with homosexual orientation,” according to a media release posted on Sept. 27.

“[Those] were people who experienced no meaningful benefit from the experience or who found it to be a failure and had gone back to their gay identity and embraced various forms of what it means to live life as a homosexual person,” Jones said.

On Aug. 5, 2009, the American Psychological Association adopted a resolution stating that mental health professionals should avoid telling clients that they can change their sexual orientation through therapy or other treatments.

Since the publication of the Jones and Yarhouse study, psychology professionals have questioned the validity of their findings.

“There is overwhelming evidence that sexual orientation is a physiological issue and not a choice, so this study standing alone isn’t going to carry a whole lot of validity without replication. It is going against all previous studies [about sexual orientation] … I would want to see repetition in their findings before I put a whole lot of stock in [them],” Kathryn Tornquist, psychotherapist and psychiatric nurse, said.

Tornquist believes a longer study will contradict the Stanton and Yarhouse study’s findings and questions whether Exodus Ministries’ views of homosexuality affected participants.

“Our culture is so judgmental of homosexuality that there’s a lot of pressure [on gay individuals] to be heterosexual. So, if they already have the particular notion that [being gay] is a sin, there’s huge pressure to change that. We also have good evidence that the belief system of investigators affects participants, even in a double blind [study],” Tornquist said.

“This study raises some questions that need to be looked at. Why? Why are these individuals changing in a way that previous evidence states is not possible or likely to happen?” 

The study followed participants over the course of six to seven years, according to the media release. From their findings, Jones and Yarhouse proposed that over time gay individuals can change their sexual orientation to heterosexual.


 

Comments  

 
#10 Get Over It 2011-11-03 23:23
The article wasn't that bad... cut the Vidette some slack. They atleast reported on the study and published an opinion piece too. I give the DV kudos for thier willingness to cover a variety of topics, even the most controversial.
Quote
 
 
#9 Xochitl 2011-10-28 18:22
For those that are upset with the fact that this study was published, think about it. You should be more upset with fact that these religious professors decided to conduct this study in the first place.

Good thing this was published, now we can study the harm of religion on society.
Quote
 
 
#8 Get Over IT 2011-10-28 10:31
Let's not forget that the Vidette has 1st Amendment rights to publish whatever they want, just like you all have the right to complain about it. I'm sick and tired of just hearing a bunch of PC bullsh** out of everyone these days. Just get over the fact that some people believe that homosexuality is a sin, and keep occupying Blo-No or whatever the he** else you waste your time on.
Quote
 
 
#7 none 2011-10-26 21:37
Have you guys ever thought that maybe the headline could have been altered by an editor or even completly changed. Im sure that it wasnt meant to be taken the way some of you are taking it.
Quote
 
 
#6 Brendan 2011-10-26 13:50
So homosexuality is a disease? Is it contagious? Is there prescription drugs that can treat it?

Try publishing articles that aren't so incredibly senseless.
Quote
 
 
#5 Alyssa Siegele 2011-10-26 13:32
Thank you for all of your feedback. We understand how this article would speak to the study as a possible fact, given the way the headline was written and how the article was structured. We were happy to see our reporter, Douglas, discuss the issue with Kathryn Tornquist, however, and learn that many other studies contradict this one. We also see the small pool of participants and the small success rate in this study. An opinion piece will be published in Friday's newspaper in response. Again, thank you for your comments.

Sincerely,
Alyssa Siegele
Daily Vidette Editor in Chief
Quote
 
 
#4 Dr. David Barone 2011-10-26 11:53
I agree with the above criticisms of this article. The first sentence of paragraph of an article should summarize its findings. The print edition even ends before the other side is given, so that the casual reader who does not continue if left to believe the journal article is OK rather than an isolated highly contradicted finding.
Quote
 
 
#3 Daniel Black 2011-10-26 10:48
I can't believe the Vidette allowed for this article to be published with such a sensationalist headline! A study where 1/3 of the participants drop out immediately and approximately half of the remaining are "affected" is hardly substantial proof that you can "treat" homosexuality. I don't dispute the author's right to publish this article, but I'm sure many members of the LGBT and Ally community don't appreciate hearing their sexuality discussed like a disease that can be eradicated.
Quote
 
 
#2 Anonymous 2011-10-26 10:36
I am completely outraged at this article and disappointed that the Daily Vidette published this the way it was written.

I understand news is supposed to be delivered regardless of viewpoints and in an objective manner, but this displays a poor choice of rhetoric. The headline itself is awful. It should read something like, "Controversial Study Claims that Homosexuality can be Treated with Faith." Instead, it blatantly says homosexuality is something that NEEDS to be treated which IT IS NOT.

If this was about racism, it wouldn't be published. If the headline was something about white people being better and black people needing to be treated with faith, it wouldn't have been published. You need to be more careful with your words and realize the effects of your words.

I didn't know the Daily Vidette wanted to promote an anti-gay image. I hope you are ashamed.
Quote
 
 
#1 Tyler Durden 2011-10-26 10:31
This may be the poorest piece of journalism I have read from the Vidette.
Quote
 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Banner
Banner
Banner